Hursthouse virtue theory and abortion. Virtue Theory and Abortion Essay 2019-03-08

Hursthouse virtue theory and abortion Rating: 4,7/10 211 reviews

Rosalind Hursthouse

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

I only have a brief response. According to virtue theory, Hursthouse declares, these discussions are also irrelevant as they circumvent the moral issue altogether. Problems Faced Both by Virtue Theories and by Kantian Theories a. What virtue would be appealed to to say it was the right action assuming other options are viable? While one story talks about how abortion is bad and makes you look at it through different examples of things, the other describes how a righteous person sees it. Here is a second consideration, especially relevant since I know Hursthouse has an aversion to dealing in abstract or isolated moral scenarios I am an ex student : any case of pregnancy has its circumstances which a person or two people with certain character constitutions are responsible for.

Next

Virtue Theory and Abortion by Angelica H on Prezi

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

Clayton, Australia: Monash University Publishing. Life has value dead things? In fact that moral blindness is such a sad comment on his moral theory. The hoplites, the Spartans, the macedonian phalanxes, the roman centurions of the legions…all were founded on virtue or seen retrospectively and ideally as being inspirations of virtue. These questions, she demonstrates, are answered in part by formulating principles. Like Man… I must admit my ignorance and say I am lost. Virtue-parenthood as an intrinsically worthwhile way of life—as an example of human flourishing. Hursthouse In this paper I will be comparing and contrasting Thomsons A Defense of Abortion and Hursthouses Virtue Theory and Abortions.

Next

Rosalinda Hursthouse

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

Abortion is a choice the mind makes for the body when the body is unable to naturally make this decision. Cite this article as: Kornegay, R. But we would not do it frivolously. Approaching the issue of abortion through the lens of Aristotelian ethics. She chooses act-utilitarianism and shows that according to this theory an action might be considered correct only when it produces the greatest amount of good for the people involved. Problem of vicious circularity that is, virtue theory is supposed to specify right action in terms of the virtuous person, and then immediately to specify the virtuous person in terms of right action —Hursthouse responds by saying that this is not true; virtue theory characterizes the virtuous person in terms of the virtues, and then characterizes the virtues in terms of certain character traits. Like the egg, removing it on purpose once it has attached to the wall is not the same as committing an immoral act of murder.

Next

Article 2: Rosalind Hursthouse Virtue and abortion

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

So, I have tried to couch the discussion there under the assumptions made by Thompson. It says that people who have… 1017 Words 5 Pages views of Rosalind Hursthouse regarding virtue ethics and abortion, and applying her ideas to the aforementioned scenario, we can assess how virtue theory would deliberate this particular moral problem. Now granted, we would not want to say that the poor lack freedom of choice which might be implicated by the above theory. The Aristotlean view of human reproduction erroneously postulated that there was a fully formed human being in the seminal fluid. If getting an abortion is not the same as murdering an innocent person, thus not a vice, then must it be a virtue? This is considered so because virtue is a naturally occurring phenomenon in a species that needs it to live well. Now, the considerations you raise are very well connected to abortion in general but they are not salient for the specific argument I was giving. Yes, Aristotle did not think highly of women, but one need not adopt his entire ethical view in order to take on his fundamental concepts and virtues as a starting place for an ethical theory.

Next

Abortion and Virtue Ethics

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

Heimir Giersson and Margaret Reed Holmgren Eds. Under circumstances in which eudaimonia is to be promoted, the assertion of individual rights become unfounded. Doing nothing is merely letting someone die. Ethical and philosophical discussions certainly hold importance as they may lead to a new conclusion which can be dispersed to others embroiled in a similar quandry. The great thing about these topics is that being a philosopher or ethicist is not a prerequisite to have a take on the issue. As a person learns to read a book, we learn virtue by practicing, not by thinking about it.

Next

Hursthouse’s Virtue Ethics and Abortion: Abortion Ethics without Metaphysics

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

The right of unborn infant, the right of mother, the right of the father, the human responsibility of life and life related issues …are some of the central elements of the abortion ethical dilemma. Rather, the theory centralizes the human being as opposed to the person as one who is in possession of the character traits necessary to promote eudaimonia. A virtuous person might be said to avoid the circumstances and situations which lead to unwanted pregnancies. As Hursthouse's paper is frequently taught, this article would provide a good counterpoint to it. If I get pregnant, and get an abortion in a few months, am I not acting as a virtuous person would act? By doing so, theories they create are fundamentally different than those created by ancient philosophers whom began by asking, which traits make one an ethical person? The introduction to the theory involves an explanation of and then contrast with deontological and utilitarian theories. Virtue theory is committed to reductionism that is, to defining all actions in terms of virtuous agents —Hursthouse responds by saying that virtue theory relies on a number of significant moral concepts, for example, benevolence, good and evil, worthwhile, advantageous and pleasant. According to Rosalind Hursthouse, an action is right from a Virtue Ethical perspective if and only if it is what the virtuous agent would do in the same circumstances.

Next

Virtue Theory And Abortion By Rosalind Hursthouse

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

He considers that there are certain environmental factors that come into play in whether an agent is virtuous. In Graham, Oppy; Trakakis, N. Also, an appeal to what most people would do does not seem to be a good way to go about what we ought to do. You mention that a virtuous person might care about protecting the rights of all human beings. A woman who becomes pregnant as a result of a rape is in a truly tragic and difficult situation.

Next

Abortion and Virtue Ethics

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

The two share similar concerns of abortion and that is if the status of the fetus is a human being or a clump of cells and also the right of the woman. Like Thomson, I believe there are circumstances where abortion is permissible. Judith Jarvis Thompson has argued that even if it is a person it is still morally permissible to have an abortion. Abortion is a terrible tragedy, and I know that many women are under emotional stress and even under pressure to abort during a crisis pregnancy. However, the result has been to remove it from the context of humanity.

Next

Rosalinda Hursthouse

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

The familiar biological facts b. On the contrary, a virtue according to virtue theory is a trait that is necessary in order to promote the wellbeing of the human. Hursthouse then gets into the application of virtue ethics to the issue of abortion. So please feel free to chime in then as well. Its also a little annoying that its hard to tell where her opinion begins and ends.

Next

Hursthouse’s Virtue Ethics and Abortion: Abortion Ethics without Metaphysics?

hursthouse virtue theory and abortion

Again, thanks for your comments. These include such things as education, wealth, free birth etc. Although pleasure is a very important and necessary aspect in our lives… agree with Hursthouse 's statement. To this end, it presents and then develops her fetal metaphysics of the potential and actual human being, which she merely adumbrates in her more extensive treatment of abortion ethics in her book Beginning Lives. Similar to a board game. I was assuming a particular view of the fetus, mainly, that it is a person. Rather, the theory appeals to these virtues and, in a given situation, asks the question of whether one is behaving in accordance with justness, kindness, bravery or any other virtue.

Next