Historical comparative research. Historical comparative research 2019-01-12
Historical comparative research Rating:
8,2/10
1771
reviews
Historical Comparative Research
Field research has replaced ethnography and ethnomethodology, older methods of research. New York: Cambridge University Press. In respect of the practical problem of complexity, any increase in the cases will so expand the number of relevant variables that the complexity becomes unmanageable. An understanding of it based on a first glance is rarely possible. Annual Review of Sociology, 30:81-101. During an event, people can get swept up in the moment and not see the full picture.
As mentioned above causal relationships are difficult to support although we make causal assumptions daily. Why is there this tendency to a limited number? John Calvin, a French theologian, was an important figure in the Protestant reformation of Christianity. Sociologists interested in history are likely to use unobtrusive methods, which are also well suited to comparative research. For example, although a revolution arises out of a distinctive historical situation, revolutions in general share certain traits that account for their dramatic political changes. Berkeley: University of California Press. Historical and cross-cultural knowledge is incomplete and provisional, based on selective facts and limited questions.
Comparative History Research Paper ⋆ Research Paper Examples ⋆ EssayEmpire
Another influential approach to the formation of modern states highlights the changing bases of political authority in societies with hereditary rulers and in societies in which rulers appeal to their subjects for legitimacy. Spatially, cross-national comparisons are by far the most common, although comparisons within countries, contrasting different areas, cultures or governments also subsist and are very constructive, especially in a country like New Zealand, where policy often changes depending on which race it pertains to. The Japanese colonial empire, beginning with Taiwan and Korea and later Manchuria, was viewed by many in the Japanese government as a tightly knit regional political and economic order designed to support Japan and secure it from threats posed by Western powers. Prohibition era includes: D a. Historical comparative sociology differs from historical sociology by focusing only on three main issues. When it comes to method, the majority agreement is that there is no methodology peculiar to comparative research. It is also appropriate for comparing entire social system to see what is common across societies and what is unique, and to study long term change.
Which of the following is not a way to perform data verification in qualitative research: C a. The comparative historical method, first introduced by the French scholar Marc Bloch, stresses the idea of a common universal history among even the most unrelated of societies. The following video on social science methods provides a comprehensive discussion of the historical comparative method and expands upon the information in this module. Other types of research may simply examine a particular outcome or event at certain point in time, while this type of research is concerned with the progression of events and circumstances. Interviewers can reveal their personal background or interests to the interviewee to build trust and rapport.
They do not argue that one specific theory is better than the other just that a theory needs to be used. A qualitative style in which a researcher directly observes a setting but does not actively interact in it. Historical-Comparative Methodologies Can draw on both qualitative and quantitative methods, often combining several methodologies. The anthropologist Jack Goody has argued that societies across Eurasia, from Japan to England and most points in between, shared structurally similar kinds of kinship systems, demographic regimes, and social structures. But there have also been comparisons that set this vast land mass off from still other continents.
But hindsight allows researchers, as well as normal people, to see the outcome of the event and trace it backwards to its source. Robert Brenner also wrote an influential study comparing English agrarian social relations with those on the European continent 1976 ; he argued that it was English social relations that made possible increased agricultural productivity and surpluses that financed the formation of commercial capitalism. . Secondary analysis of quantitative data is relatively widespread in comparative research, undoubtedly in part because of the cost of obtaining primary data for such large things as a country's policy environment. Many researchers find that ideas and questions arise when they read other people's research.
Journal of Agrarian Change, 1. Researchers must avoid all conflict and stay neutral. The Logic of Comparative Social Inquiry. An H-C researcher may apply a theory to specific cases to illustrate its usefulness. The comparative-historical method can be seen in The Familial State: Ruling Families and Merchant Capitalism in Early Modern Europe. Once the research question has been identified, the researcher needs to determine the specific methodology for data collection. Does the story the researcher tells with his or her data match what the study participants shared? This study is generally aggregate data analysis.
Historical Research Design: Definition, Advantages & Limitations
Both methods aim to understand complexities and identify causal mechanisms. Tracking how democracy developed is a daunting task for one country or region let alone three. Yet, many recent historical comparisons have also moved beyond simple dichotomies, highlighting in more nuanced ways both similarities and differences and the way they interact to produce unique historical outcomes. American Sociological Review 28: 532—9. Research in the social sciences is restricted by the relatively small number of societies in which the investigator is interested for theoretical and substantive reasons. They are usually lazier than quantitative researchers.
